In his report on NEETS – young people Not in Education, Employment or Training –Alan Milburn admits that whatever policies he introduces will take a good decade to bear fruit. In the meantime, we need to empower these young people to believe in themselves and their future. Referring to them as a potential “lost generation” or “the left-behind” generation is, in my view, unhelpful. It just increases the sense of panic that they are victims of circumstance and that their situation is uniquely terrible. Even the term NEETS is negative. How about SEETS – Seeking Education, Employment or Training?
I believe it is important to change the messaging. Yes, this generation certainly has specific problems but the catastrophising language that the MSM, social media and government are applying simply emphasises their lack of agency. What we need to do is to empower them to believe they can succeed, despite the circumstances. There are several ways I think we can help them do this.
- Every Generation Has Faced an Uncertain Future
May I suggest that teachers, mentors, journalists, parents and government representatives teach some history? Help these young people to imagine what it might have been like to be my grandfather or grandmother who lived through World War I and II, who faced the problems of living through the great depression of the 1930s. Help them to imagine what it might have been like to be my parents, who got married on November 24 1939, in their early 20s, on the brink of war and, like so many young couples of their time, were separated, faced bombs, fear and uncertainty. Help them to imagine what it was like to be a young person trying to rebuild this country after World War II – I remember passing huge bomb sites when we visited London and other cities. More recently, the global financial crisis of 2008 created unemployment reaching 8.5% in 2011. And then perhaps imagine being a teenager in Ukraine. Human ingenuity and resilience can come to the fore in the midst of challenge, as gradually people learn new skills, developed new organisations.
Life is always uncertain. We never accurately predict the future. No-one, in my grandmother’s time had the benefit of the NHS (my mother had her tonsils out on the kitchen table). People did not predict how the computer and technology revolution would transform our lives, let alone AI. Yes, there is inevitable suffering in life but the will to survive drives us forward. As the saying goes “all things will pass.” Life moves on and even if new innovation looks as if it may take all the jobs, the opposite is sometimes true. New ways of doing things can also create jobs.
Context and perspective can empower individuals to believe that the past is not necessarily going to be a predictor of the future; that they can say, “Yes, I have this problem but thank heavens I don’t also have that problem.” Gratitude really can help people open their eyes to what they do have rather than what they don’t, which helps them feel more confident and optimistic – and optimism is essential if they are to apply for work or set up a business.
- Change your thoughts and you change your life
It’s easy to get into a downward spiral of negative habits of thinking, behaviours and actions. We are deeply habitual creatures and so if someone sits at home alone in a room for a few days it becomes harder for them, whatever their age, to get out and talk to people or try something new. I wrote two other articles on this subject:
Thoughts influence feelings and so it is helpful to encourage a young person to identify some of their negative thinking. For example, if someone thinks “it will never work” or “everyone thinks I am hopeless” that is likely to make them feel more anxious. If they are feeling anxious, their breathing changes into their upper chest, their voice becomes constricted and they are less likely to appear or act confident.
Notice generalisations and dramatizations like “nothing is going my way” and ask them whether they can think of just one thing that is going their way. Then build on that.
Changing thoughts takes practice – it is literally like learning a new language but if they can convince themselves to feel the fear but try it anyway, and train themselves to think “I will learn more from giving it a try than I will from sitting at home” then that impacts emotions, behaviours and actions. This is where the fear of failure can paralyse but taking an action, even if it doesn’t work out, can breed confidence because they can tell themselves, “at least I tried”. Step by step small changes of thought, behaviour and action increase confidence.
- Recognise that feelings are infectious
I read today that 45% of NEETS report having a work-limiting condition. This is a huge figure, and it is hard to understand how this outcome has occurred, but it is also important to remember that any diagnosis does not have to mean they cannot achieve success. David Blunkett wrote an article in The Sunday Times recounting how his blindness did not stop him deciding he would find a way to make a career for himself. It takes patience and determination, and the ability to face failure and adversity but to keep on trying can lead to a sense of fulfilment even if the precise goal is not achieved.
Emotions are infectious. If one person in a group says they are anxious then it can stimulate anxiety in others through peer empathy and groupthink. If one person cries others often find tears in their eyes. Likewise, if one person says they are excited about something others can catch their enthusiasm. I should know, I was a Beatlemaniac and if one girl screamed at a concert we all screamed!
And yet within any peer group there may actually be many different levels of an emotion but there can be peer pressure, especially as teenagers, to all feel the same way. That may or may not be helpful and requires self-awareness. Help them develop the ability to observe others and not automatically feel they must feel the same way as them.
- Group Support and Networking
Being out of work, education or training can be isolating yet in order to find work it is necessary to build social skills and to network. Volunteering can provide a focus and is useful in a cv. Building a WhatsApp Group and meeting in person to chat and support one another could be helpful – though it is important that these meetings are not just a general moan. Use the time to talk about what they can do and what is helpful rather than what is not. Use the time to practice interview skills and get feedback in a non-judgemental environment. The reality is that the more people who know someone is looking for work or training the more that person’s network builds and this could lead to someone – perhaps a parent or the employer of a friend – being able to offer them some opportunity. That opportunity is far less likely to appear if they stay hidden in their bedroom.
In these groups they can help each other ask coaching questions like:
- What are your skills?
- What are the strengths you have gained through your childhood? Even a difficult childhood can give people strengths, skills and perspectives that others may not be able to offer.
- What would you like to be doing in 3 years’ time? Why?
- What do you enjoy spending time doing or thinking about?
- What personal qualities do you have that could make a positive difference to an employer and a team?
- What do you bring, as a human, that AI cannot bring?
- How might you express your skills, strengths and qualities in a cv, job application or interview?
- Show us how you might stand and present yourself if you imagine feeling confident.
It’s important that the focus of any meeting, whether in person (preferable as it gets people out) or online is positive – not Pollyanna positive, imagining everything will go perfectly, but rationally optimistic.
- Companies and Government can play their part
There are things companies and the government can do to help young people. Companies are criticised for not acknowledging applications or cvs and not giving feedback from interviews. This is ghosting, disillusioning and the person learns nothing. It is better if a human being responds but if this is not possible then it is surely not impossible, in this age of AI, for the organisation to set up an automatic AI acknowledgement of a cv or application to demonstrate it has been read. Equally if someone comes to an interview the transcript could be summarised and AI could provide some constructive feedback to the applicant, if no human is available to do so.
Government can, as Alan Milburn is suggesting, analyse and moderate the benefits a NEET receives. I believe this is a balance between what the state can do and what the young person can do. The message needs to encourage the young person to act. The one phrase I disagreed with in David Blunkett’s article was suggesting that young people say to themselves, “I must be supported in getting a job so that I’m no longer depressed and overcome.” A more useful phrase, I think, might be “I would prefer it if the government arranged a job for me, but I can try to find solutions for myself if they don’t.” This creates a blend of personal agency with external support. Also, it can be a disincentive to have too much of a financial safety blanket. I set up my coaching company Positiveworks in the recession of 1992. I was in the middle of a divorce, moving house and my father was dying but I felt I had to make an income, yet I knew others who had received redundancy packages who had less immediate need to take those critical steps forward.
Government can also take action to review their employment policies around National Insurance, minimum wage, EU freedom of movement, and zero-hours contracts to analyse whether these are ultimately helpful in this current situation.
- The Lost Generation? Only If We Give Up on Them
Let’s stop using phrases such as the “lost” or “left-behind” generation or over-emphasising the problems. If you talk about young people as if they are victims, they think of themselves as such and can fall into a helpless-hopeless state of “what’s the point?”
Let’s remind these young people that they are unique, for each human being is unique. They have unique qualities, skills and experiences to contribute to the future of this country. Let’s reassure them that we believe in them and so we hope they will believe in themselves.
We can’t promise them a future without challenge but let’s remind them that there have been worse moments in history and that everything changes, that uncertainty is a fact of life and the human condition is such that we have extraordinary abilities to overcome adversity and make something of our lives. Let’s help them feel excited about the future and feel that they can shape it. Whatever their background or special needs, they can be encouraged to believe that they can make a difference and have something to offer.
Let’s give them the confidence and impetus to feel the fear and take some action anyway.
Recent Comments